Dear Dot: What Can I Do With My Halloween Pumpkin?

Author:

Category:

Note that if you purchase something via one of our links, including Amazon, we may earn a small commission.

Dear Dot,

My family loves Halloween, and we go a bit overboard with pumpkins. Any advice for what I can do with them when the holiday is over besides tossing them?

– Annette

Dear Annette,

It’s something of a Dot family tradition. At the last possible minute, Mr. Dot, caving to the pleas of the Little Dots, would trek to a nearby farm, select one of the remaining misshapen pumpkins, then carve in a standard jack-o’-lantern grin before placing the leering gourd on our front porch. There it would lure trick-or-treaters then slowly decompose, growing more ghoulish with each passing day. As you note, Annette, surely there’s a better way.

The University of California reports that, each year, the U.S. produces more than 2 billion pounds of pumpkins. And 80% of those gourds end up in the trash. In Canada, the CBC tells us that, “There are more than 2,500 farms in Canada with pumpkin patches, according to Statistics Canada. Collectively, they produce 80 thousand metric tonnes of pumpkins, with about two-thirds sold fresh to customers. Most of those, however, are never eaten. Instead, we carve faces in them, light them up, and throw them out.”

We forget, Annette, that those pumpkins are actually food. If not for us, then for animals. 

So let’s consider how we might dispose of our pumpkins — carved or not — in a way that respects the Earth.

Eat it: Uncarved pumpkins are perfectly safe to eat, even if they’ve been sitting on your front porch for a few weeks as long as they’re still firm and free of mold. Purée their flesh into pies and soups or these out-of-this-world muffins using sourdough discard. Even Rover can benefit from some pumpkin (as long as nothing else is added). 

Compost it: A carved pumpkin can still feed your compost. Chop it up into smaller chunks and add it to your municipal green bin program or backyard compost where it will add nitrogen. Though please scrape out any candle wax first.

Give it to the birds: Cut your carved pumpkin in half and fill it with bird seed, then hang it from a tree (or place it on a tree stump or other platform) to feed your local birds. 

Give it to a pig: Pumpkins for Pigs will feed your pumpkins to livestock — find a donor site here. If you can’t find a nearby site, the organization encourages you to ask around at your local farmers market and holiday pop-up markets, focusing on egg and meat producers; or seek out a farm or animal rescue. 

A few caveats, Annette: Don’t dump old pumpkins in the woods or local parks. If your pumpkin is painted, throw it out. 

Published:

Last Modified:

Latest Stories

Dear Dot
Dear Dot
Dear Dot is here to answer all your sustainable living questions from her perch on the porch. Got a question for Dot? Send her a note for a chance to be featured in an upcoming post.
Read More

Related Articles