Note that if you purchase something via one of our links, including Amazon, we may earn a small commission.
The holidays are a time to remember the community you love and care about, and gifting is a great way to do that. It seems daunting to combine sustainability and gifting but I promise it’s easier than you’d think.
The goal of gifting is to show someone you love and appreciate them and one way to do that is with a thoughtful gift. There’s no need to get swept up in the overconsumption of it all — the simplest, truest gifts are usually the best. Plus, sometimes they’re the most cost-effective gifts!
When shopping this season, here are some ideas to consider:
- Quality over quantity: Although it’s fun to give multiple gifts, we often sacrifice quality for cost. This year, focus on well-made items that can last through the years.
- Look at the materials: When buying clothes for someone, consider what the item is made out of. Polyester has gotten so good that it can pass as cotton, but it’s not nearly as durable or worth it (there’s a lot of discourse in the fashion world about how a polyester shirt can cost $300 when the materials cost almost nothing.) Plus, polyester sheds microplastics. Look for garments made from silk, cotton, wool, linen, cashmere, or recycled polyester. Chances are, if the brand splurged for the better fabric, they’ll give you a better construction as well.
- Eat your gifts: As we get older, we need less. Edible gifts, such as spice mixes (like those from Burlap and Barrel or Diaspora Co. Spices), high-quality olive oil (consider Graza — they offer refill cans!), wine, and liquor can go a long way. If you want to enhance the present, etch the bottle with a message or a date. Get etching paint from Michaels and you’re well on your way to a perfect gift.
- DIY: To many of us, the idea of a DIY gift can be terribly overwhelming. I’m not suggesting you get on a pottery wheel or start knitting right now — though hand-thrown bowls and knitwear are fantastic gifts — but there are DIY gifts to appease everyone. Have a bunch of little jars hanging around? Make some candied nuts (I swear it’s the easiest thing I’ve ever made), pop them in the jar, and enjoy the smiles of the happy snackers you pass them on to. To take it up a notch: take scrap fabric and cut out a circle about 2 inches bigger than the jar. Place the fabric over the lid and use a ribbon to tie it all together. Voila! You’ve even DIY-ed cute packaging.
- Multipurpose: Weird, single-purpose tools, especially kitchen gadgets, do little more than take up time, space, and energy to produce. Most people will continue reaching for tried-and-true tools rather than ones that claim to save you time and energy (have you ever tried to clean a banana slicer? It’s not worth the ease of slicing a banana). Make sure that if you’re giving a gift, there’s a genuine use or a genuine joy to it.
- Shop Small and Sustainable: Small Business Saturday this year is November 30, 2024. Buying from local artisans at a holiday market is one of the best ways to shop sustainably. Not only do you cut out shipping, but you’re supporting small makers who work hard to create high-quality products. Or, look to sustainable marketplaces such as the Bluedot Living Marketplace, Commons, EarthHero, Zero-Waste Store, Goodee, and more. In-person marketplaces are all over Brooklyn such as FAD Market pop-up (multiple locations), Artists & Fleas in Williamsburg, Wallabout Wonderland in Brooklyn Navy Yard, and more.
- Refurbished recommendations: When looking at more expensive items, buying a refurbished version both saves money and saves stuff from going into the landfill. Also, buying from trusted sources means that your item will be just like new but maybe without the satisfying packaging. BackMarket sells quality-assured refurbished tech for a good deal. For outdoor gear of any kind consider Patagonia Worn Wear and The North Face Renewed — both are marketplaces for older models of the company’s products that they patch up, clean up, and re-sell for about half the price. Unless you select the lowest condition or are looking for specific packaging, you usually can’t tell that it was a refurbished product.
- A “don’t want” list is allowed: It is okay to tell people “Please, don’t give me any more blankets this year” if your home is chock-full. In general, it feels nicer to give a gift someone wants and needs rather than one that will end up buried in a closet. If you’re trying to cut down on plastics, ask that people give you gifts made from natural materials. If you know that you’re moving somewhere warm, ask them to hold the mittens. But, alas, if you’re gifted despite your requests, make sure you donate any unwanted items.
- New-to-you: Many items on a Christmas list can be given second-hand — aka “new-to-you” gifts. Gifting this way reduces the need to produce a new item and reduces the impact of the gift. Plus, finding a vintage key hanger for your friend’s entryway can be a unique and lasting present. Second-hand items may not be perfectly new and fresh out of the box, but especially with items like books (and we have a great list of climate books here if you’re interested), second-hand doesn’t mean the item is diminished, it’s just being passed along. Thriftbooks lets you pick your quality of second-hand books and even sells new ones. I buy the lowest-quality books for myself and gift “excellent” quality books to friends and family. Another good marketplace for pre-loved items is eBay — shop there and you never know what treasures you may find.
- Minis are only sometimes cute: Beauty brands know that we love minis. You can try a product or buy a smaller version for half the price by buying minis. Minis are, unfortunately, a huge waste of packaging — most beauty products are, in general, wasteful with their packaging. If you want to gift beauty products look for tried-and-true items in full size. Instead of a pocket-sized hand creme as a gifted add-on, opt for the full-sized (and much nicer-looking) jar. Instead of a holiday-themed chapstick, get the internet-approved Laneige Lip Mask. One of the best housewarming gifts I was ever given was a hand soap from Aesop.
More than anything, a good gift is one you put thought into. If it is a gift that doesn’t succumb to overconsumption and is made of sustainable materials then it’s a double win. But you don’t need a gift to change your life or someone else’s life. Enjoy the season, and remember that every little decision helps.

